L'Agenda du GIS

L’entraide mutuelle à une époque d’incertitude en Afrique

L’entraide mutuelle à une époque d’incertitude en Afrique



ByDaivi Rodima-Taylor and Erik Bähre

Le thème de l’informalité contemporaine dans l’évolution des régimes de régulation et de la bureaucratie a été examiné en 2012, dans un  numéro spécial de la revue Africa qui portait sur la question des «économies populaires en Afrique du Sud» (Hull et James 2012). Au lieu de considérer l’informalité comme périphérique à l’économie, ce dossier spécial a révélé que les pratiques économiques et les idéologies sont mieux comprises en plaçant l’informalisation au centre de l’analyse. Le cluster d’articles réunis dans ce numéro-ci sur la cette question de l’entraide mutuelle, élargit ces préoccupations avec des perspectives comparatives sur mutualités africaines, soulignant l’importance des éléments affectifs et normatifs de solidarité et de coopération moderne.

African communities are witnessing a perplexing proliferation of diverse arrangements of mutual security that draw upon old and new solidarities and inventively merge market logic with reciprocal forms of distribution and sharing. The dynamics of such voluntary arrangements and their broader social impacts emerge as increasingly important topics of study. The changing nature of global economies poses challenging questions about the novel relationships between state and market, and the potential of human agency to find alternatives to address growing inequalities. This collection focuses on local institutions of mutual security as alternative – yet also interdependent – forms of distribution that have become particularly relevant in the current era of global financialization and the changing dynamics between private and public social spheres. Various voluntary associations and informal economic networks, financial mutuals and savings/credit groups are becoming central in regulating access to resources and defining patterns of association in African communities. The articles in this themed part-issue explore these social security networks and organizations, concentrating on their ambiguous potential to empower the marginal as well as to contribute to social strife and political conflict. Ethnographic cases from diverse parts of Africa illustrate the impacts of the environments of uncertainty on the emergence of novel forms of association. The contributions suggest that contemporary mutual help arrangements should be seen as being central to the emergence of new social spaces and power configurations in such settings, revealing a broader social dynamic of globalization.

(…) African economies are increasingly affected by global financial instabilities and the changing role of money in social life. Global financial deregulation has led to a proliferation of innovative financial products and the increasing ‘financialization’ of world economies, with a focus on credit and private investment, highlighting the need to reconsider the relationships between the state and the market (Maurer 2005; Hart and Ortiz 2008). In the anthropological study of the distribution of resources, a fuller integration of the financial with the social and the political is called for. Alternative and informal modes of distribution that draw upon novel arrangements of solidarity have become particularly relevant in African communities over the past few decades of neoliberal deregulation reforms. An unprecedented growth in informal economic arrangements has occurred, encompassing diverse social and ethnic categories and facilitating the emergence of new public spaces and moralities (Lindell 2010; Bryceson 2010). The ongoing global expansion of the financial sector and the ideology of financial inclusion underline the importance of alternative sources of finance for people’s livelihoods (cf. Hull and James 2012). The resulting plural economic forms that strive to balance the tension between self-interest and mutuality can be seen as a distinguishing feature of the contemporary human economy (Hart et al.2010). Instead of assuming a trend towards an increasing abstraction of finance, it is important to investigate diverse local ‘monetary repertoires and practices’ (Maurer 2005: 17; Guyer 2004; see also Bähre 2007; Rodima-Taylor 2013).

Although mutual security associations play an increasingly important role in the emerging configurations of network governance in many African societies (see also Comaroff and Comaroff 2012; Meagher 2010), there is still scarce anthropological study of mutual help in its contemporary forms. The relationship between mutuality and its organizational forms is emerging as a central area of investigation. Recent ethnographies highlight a tendency towards an informal formalization of mutual help arrangements and the importance of ritual and symbolic aspects in legitimizing novel types of solidarities. This collection of articles aims to contribute to the study of the uneven and partial formalization of institutions of mutuality, with a particular focus on diverse modes of belonging and identity in the new networks of solidarity in Africa.

The topic of contemporary informality within changing regulatory regimes and bureaucracy was examined in the 2012 Africaspecial issue ‘Popular economies in South Africa’ (Hull and James 2012). Instead of viewing informality as peripheral to the economy, the collection revealed that economic practices and ideologies are best understood by placing informalization at the centre of the analysis. The cluster of papers in this issue expands these concerns with comparative perspectives on African mutualities, highlighting the importance of affective and normative elements of modern solidarity and cooperation.

Lire la suite dans la revue Africa